Lexicon wrote:Well, the big problems with the whole KARR reactivation plotline are the following...
1. KITT and KARR are two distinctly different AI entities. Removing KITT's AI chip (which apparently contains everything that is KITT) and putting it in KARR would only result in KITT being reactivated in KARR's shell. The real question here is just what did they need KITT's AI chip for? Graiman's dialog implied that they were going to somehow merge KITT's AI with KARR's AI yet the actions of Torres and the way the episode was outlined implied that KITT was going to be plunked into KARR as I outlined above. Makes little sense to me.
KI3T's chip would be a control chip - but they were going to use elements of KI3T's programming, and his applications, in KARR. Remember, Torres said "Kitt isn't plug and play, we've got to have development time" or something like that. If I remember correctly, it took around 6 hours for everything to sync correctly.
From a computer standpoint, KARR would be the primary AI controller, accessing KI3T's programming and functions when needed. KI3T's personality wouldn't exist within KARR.
2. In the previous episode, there was a bit between Billy and Zoe where Zoe said that she overheard Torres saying that "KARR lives!". That implies that KARR is functional, at least on a basic level, so we can assume that those files helped them reactivate KARR. If Billy can put together a suitable replacement for KITT's removed chip, then it's logical to assume that the government group can certainly do the same if not significantly better given their funding.
"KARR lives" was referring to the project, not necessarily the entity. The project was still alive, and the prototype wasn't dismantled.
KI3T was a Graiman creation - the government didn't have the specs for KI3T's chip or AI, which is why they didn't fabricate one. Billy had the specs (and apparently the parts) needed to create a new one. How he got the parts necessary, I have no idea (I don't think CompUSA sells AI chips). :-\
3. We don't know precisely (and the writers don't seem to know either) what exactly happened with KARR other than he went bonkers after programming himself and he killed at least several people. We don't know what precipitated that or have any idea as to the evolution of KARR apart from his being the first of the new generation of Knight Industries AI controlled vehicles.
I think that was supposed to be explored in Mike's backstory....but we'll probably never see that. He apparently killed because he was unable to distinguish between humans and targets, or something like that - that could be for any reason. I just chalked it up to faulty AI. As to what happened after the killings, I'm sure he was deactivated. I doubt the government would let him hang out at any coffee shops or anything.
4. KITT should still exist inside the original AI chip unless the government folks replaced his AI with KARR's. So confusing!
They did. KI3T's programming and everything is on the chip - all of his data - but KARR's AI is using it. Think of dual-booting a system with multiple hard drives. One can have Windows and the other might have Linux. You only use one operating system at a time, but the operating system sees the data on both drives and can use it. Made sense to me, anyway (although I doubt that in practicality, it's really not all that simple).

If I am destroyed... ...so shall you be. -KARR